Losing to Win: Embracing Losses in Rule Breaker Investing

PODCAST INFORMATION

  • Podcast: Rule Breaker Investing
  • Episode: Loosing to Win
  • Host: David Gardner
  • Duration: Approximately 49 minutes
  • E-E-A-T Assessment: Experience: David Gardner demonstrates extensive first-hand experience as a long-term investor and co-founder of The Motley Fool with decades of investment track record Expertise: Shows deep knowledge of investment principles, market dynamics, and specific companies with concrete examples and historical performance data Authoritativeness: As a co-founder of The Motley Fool and author of investment books, Gardner is recognized as an authority in the investment education space Trust: Transparent about both successes and failures, provides specific examples, and acknowledges limitations of his approach

🎧 Listen here

🎯 HOOK

Psychologists tell us the pain of losing is three times the joy of winning, but what if the mathematics of investing completely overturn this fundamental human truth?

💡 ONE-SENTENCE TAKEAWAY

Successful Rule Breaker investing requires embracing losses because the unlimited upside potential of big winners mathematically outweighs the finite downside of even your worst investments.

📖 SUMMARY

In this episode, David Gardner explores the counterintuitive concept of “losing to win”, the idea that embracing investment losses is essential to long-term success. He begins by reviewing a “5 Stocks That Let You Eat Cake” sampler from three years ago, showing both winners and losers to illustrate his point.

The sampler results were mixed: 2U (down 50.2%), CBOE Global Markets (down 27%), NVIDIA (up 149%), Amazon (up 172%), and Match Group (up 340%). Despite two significant losers, the overall performance beat the market by 75 percentage points.

The core of the episode focuses on Gardner’s analysis of his track record across Motley Fool services. In Rule Breakers, 63 of 389 picks are down 50% or more (one in six), but the 63rd best pick (HubSpot) is up 401.8%, and his single best pick (Mercado Libre) is up 9,004.7% more than wiping out all the losses from the 63 losers combined.

A similar pattern appears in Stock Advisor: 30 of 224 picks are down 50% or more, but Netflix (up 25,737%) more than compensates for all those losses. Gardner argues that while humans are psychologically wired to feel the pain of loss three times more than the joy of gain, the mathematics of investing work differently; the joy of gain is potentially infinite while the pain of loss is capped at 100%.

This dynamic, Gardner argues, is particularly true for Rule Breaker investing, which seeks high-growth companies that can become multi-baggers. He concludes that investors must be willing to embrace losses as part of the process, recognizing that big winners will more than compensate for inevitable losers.

🔍 INSIGHTS

Core Insights

  • The psychological pain of loss (3x the joy of gain) conflicts with the mathematical reality of investing where gains are potentially unlimited while losses are capped at 100%
  • In Gardner’s Rule Breakers service, one in six picks lost 50% or more, but the single best pick (Mercado Libre up 9,004.7%) more than compensated for all those losses
  • The “losing to win” approach requires a mindset shift - viewing losses not as failures but as necessary costs of pursuing big winners
  • This investment philosophy works particularly well with Rule Breaker stocks that have the potential for exponential growth
  • The data from both Rule Breakers and Stock Advisor services consistently shows that a few big winners more than compensate for many smaller losers

How This Connects to Broader Trends/Topics

  • Contrasts with traditional value investing approaches that focus more on avoiding losses
  • Connects to venture capital principles where a few big wins must compensate for many failures
  • Relates to behavioral finance concepts around loss aversion and how investors can overcome psychological biases
  • Aligns with growth investing philosophies that prioritize finding companies with exponential potential

🛠️ FRAMEWORKS & MODELS

Losing to Win Framework

  • Core principle: Embrace losses as part of the investment process
  • Mathematical foundation: Gains are potentially unlimited while losses are capped at 100%
  • Psychological component: Overcome the natural human tendency to feel loss more acutely than gain
  • Implementation: Focus on finding companies with exponential growth potential rather than avoiding all risk
  • Evidence: Gardner’s track record shows that big winners more than compensate for numerous losers

“5 Stocks That Let You Eat Cake” Sampler

  • Theme: Finding companies that allow investors to have it both ways - combining seemingly contradictory strengths
  • Examples: Amazon (e-commerce and cloud), Match Group (traditional and modern dating platforms)
  • Review process: Three-year performance evaluation against the S&P 500
  • Results: Mixed performance but overall outperformance of the market

💬 QUOTES

  1. “Psychologists tell us that the pain of losing is three times the joy of winning. That’s the rule. Are you ready to break it, Fool?”

    • David Gardner, opening the episode
    • Significance: Sets up the central psychological conflict that the episode addresses

  2. “My superhero power is a strange one. I have an ability to lose constantly. My superhero power is the ability to lose. It’s just losing. I lose all the time, but of course, I’m losing to win.”

    • David Gardner, describing his approach to investing
    • Significance: Reframes losing not as a weakness but as a strength in the context of his investment philosophy

  3. “The 63rd best stock for Motley Fool Rule Breakers happens to be HubSpot. HubSpot is up 401.8% since I first picked it, and that is the 63rd best stock.”

    • David Gardner, presenting data on his Rule Breakers performance
    • Significance: Demonstrates how even the 63rd best pick can dramatically outperform, supporting his thesis

  4. “Our single best pick is up 9,004%. All of our 63 disasters combined lost 4,700 percentage points. In other words, our one best stock has just wiped out all of our 63 dogs and left a bunch of money on the table on top of that.”

    • David Gardner, highlighting the mathematical power of big winners
    • Significance: Provides concrete evidence for how the mathematics of investing can overcome psychological loss aversion

  5. “For investors, the joy of gain is infinite times the pain of loss. And that’s why you and I should be willing to take it on the chin as frequently as one in six times.”

    • David Gardner, summarizing his core insight
    • Significance: Captures the essence of his “losing to win” philosophy in a single statement

⚡ APPLICATIONS & HABITS

Practical Guidance

  • Accept that losses are a normal and expected part of Rule Breaker investing
  • Focus on finding companies with exponential growth potential rather than avoiding all risk
  • Maintain a long-term perspective (minimum three years) to allow winners to develop
  • Diversify across multiple Rule Breaker stocks to increase chances of finding big winners
  • Resist the psychological urge to sell losers too quickly or winners too early

Implementation Strategies

  • Build a portfolio of Rule Breaker stocks with the expectation that some will lose 50% or more
  • Hold winners through volatility to allow for exponential growth
  • Regularly review holdings against Rule Breaker principles rather than short-term price movements
  • Consider each investment as part of a portfolio approach rather than in isolation

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Don’t let the fear of losses prevent you from investing in high-potential growth stocks
  • Avoid selling winners too early - let them compound over time
  • Don’t abandon the strategy after experiencing losses - recognize them as part of the process
  • Avoid over-concentrating in too few positions despite confidence

📚 REFERENCES

  • Shirzad Chamine’s work on Positive Intelligence Quotient (PQ)
  • Historical performance data from Motley Fool Rule Breakers service (389 picks since 2004)
  • Historical performance data from Motley Fool Stock Advisor service (224 picks since 2002)
  • Specific stock performance examples: Mercado Libre (up 9,004.7%), Netflix (up 25,737%), HubSpot (up 401.8%)
  • Psychological research on loss aversion (pain of loss is 3x the joy of gain)

⚠️ QUALITY & TRUSTWORTHINESS NOTES

  • Accuracy Check: The information appears accurate with specific examples and historical performance data. Gardner provides precise numbers and percentages.
  • Bias Assessment: Gardner clearly states his bias toward Rule Breaker investing and growth stocks, but supports his approach with extensive historical data.
  • Source Credibility: Claims are backed by specific company examples and historical performance data from his own services.
  • Transparency: Gardner is transparent about both successes and failures, providing specific examples of losing positions.
  • Potential Harm: The content includes standard investment disclaimers and acknowledges that this approach isn’t suitable for everyone. Gardner explicitly notes that this style of investing requires embracing losses that many investors find uncomfortable.

Crepi il lupo! 🐺